The Volokh Conspiracy » Search Warrant for Name of the Author of ...

I blogged about this case last week ( Is It a Crime to Publish Parody Videos That Use “Lewd ... Language” Meant to “Embarrass and Emotionally Torment” Police Officers? ); yesterday, the judge stayed the search warrant aimed at unmasking the author of the videos, pending a hearing on whether the search warrant should be quashed. [UPDATE: The request to quash the warrant came from lawyer Harish Bharti , who is representing an unidentified client (who might well be the anonymous author of the videos).]

As I argued in my earlier post, under the City Attorney’s interpretation of the Washington cyberstalking statute that the videos supposedly violate, that statute violates the First Amendment and is unconstitutionally overbroad on its face; if that’s so, then the warrant should indeed be quashed, because it will not reveal evidence of criminal conduct. It will be interesting to see what ultimately happens in court. Thanks to Ed Grinberg for the pointer.

well, considering his clear ignorance of the constitution and constitutional law, i am about 99.9% certain the volokh conspiracy is probably the last place he would be looking.

maybe though, considering the impact his overreach has had, he may actually be seekingto self-educate.

let me just say... in defense of REAL COPS...a point i often make... police chiefs aren’t cops (usually)... they are cop-o-crats... political appointees with about as much in common with a real cop, as theCEO of a company has with an assembly line worker  

As this cyberlaw blog article points out , a preliminary hearing to quash a search warrant before it’s executed is unusual.

A subpoena can be challenged in this manner, but typically a search warrant is litigated after-the-fact in a suppression hearing or on a motion to return the property.


Cathy Mcdonald Of Renton Wa - Bookshelf

Of mice and men

Of mice and men

The tragic story of the friendship between two migrant workers, George and mentally retarded Lenny, and their dream of owning a farm

Fast Food Nation, The Dark Side of the All-American Meal

Fast Food Nation, The Dark Side of the All-American Meal

Analyzing the influence of the fast food industry on American society, an award-winning journalist explores the homogenization of American culture and the ...

Three cups of tea, one man's mission to fight terrorism and build nations-- one school at a time

Three cups of tea, one man's mission to fight terrorism and build nations-- one school at a time

Traces how the author, having been rescued and resuscitated by Himalayan villagers after a failed attempt to climb K2, worked to build schools that would ...

Art of War

Art of War

While appreciative of the philosophical richness of the Art of War, this edition stresses Sun-tzu's practical origins and presents a translation that is both ...

The elements of style

The elements of style

Offers advice on improving writing skills and promoting a style marked by simplicity, orderliness, and sincerity.

Daily Data Directory


The Seattle Times: Outdoors: Springbrook Trail
With the completion of the Ship Canal in 1917, the level of Lake Washington was lowered ... Cathy McDonald, a Renton-based freelance writer, is a regular ...

Outdoors | Museum of the Month: Renton Historical Museum ...
Museum of the Month: Renton Historical Museum. Museum location: 235 ... Cathy McDonald, a Renton-based freelance writer, is a regular contributor to ...

Renton, Washington - News - Evri
Follow Renton, Washington at Evri.com, your source for real time news, quotes, tweets, trends, photos and videos

WNW - City Nature Walks
When and Where to Find Winter Nature Walks in Washington State ... Cathy McDonald, 7/31/04. Point Defiance Park gardens: Forest trails in upper part of the park; sidewalk runs ...

Renton Newswire - Topix
Comprehensive Real-Time News Feed for Renton, WA. ... Renton-based freelancer Cathy McDonald, a former geologist, has written about science and nature travel for ...